Grain or not in a dog's diet?

by Mogens Eliasen


There is a standing discussion about feeding dogs grain products. Some people think it is a great idea - others argue heavily against it.

***Carnivore or omnivore?***

These classifications are man made. They can cause a lot of confusion if you try to apply them rigidly. It will suffice for you to acknowledge that there are some huge differences between the dog's gastrointestinal system and the human system. Whether both are within the spectrum of "omnivores" or the dog truly is a "carnivore" does not matter. The only thing that matters is what the dog would eat if left on its own in a natural environment.

***The ultimate authority***

There is only one authority we can rely on: Canis Lupus, the wolf - as he would feed in a natural environment. Whether you like it or not, the dog's scientific name has recently been changed from Canis Familiaris to Canis Lupus Familiaris - taking the full consequence of all the overwhelming scientific research that confirms that the dog is nothing more and nothing less than a domesticated wolf. Dogs and wolves are the same species. The genetic differences between dogs and wolves are no greater than the differences between black and white people.

For this reason, the only feeding philosophy that makes sense will be an attempt to get as close as you can to what Mother Nature would feed a wolf. The bad news is that you cannot do this perfectly - you simply don't have the supplies of whole live prey animals... and you don't want to give your dog its natural incentive to eat all the veggies it needs: starvation....

***Using grain in commercial food***

There are many powerful reasons for feeding grain:
1) Grain products are by far the cheapest source of energy you can get.
2) Grain products and their large contents of complex carbohydrates are generally considered healthy for humans, and it is easy (but completely incorrect) to conclude from this that they are also good for your dog.
3) Some dogs will gain weight (which is cosmetically desirable for some people) when fed grain.
4) Many dogs happen to like grain products as much as kids like candy, so it is easy to conclude that when the dog likes it, it is OK to feed....
5) Many dogs appear to do OK with substantial amounts of grain in their diet, at least for 7-10 years.... and it is impossible to document that it was grain that stopped their liver or their kidneys from letting it live another 3-4 years, at least in any individual case...
6) No adverse effects have been demonstrated by feeding smaller amounts of grain, as a minor supplement, and no large-scale study has ever been done to show that even substantial amounts of grain in the dog's diet can be directly related to any specific problems for any specific dog.

However, here are some good reasons for not feeding grain:

1) No canines in nature have access to grain as a significant food source, except for the small half-digested amounts they get through eating rodents whole.
2) Grain products, particularly when baked or cooked, will leave a layer of plaque on the teeth that can cause a lot of trouble because dogs do not have any enzymes in their saliva that can clean the teeth for those carbohydrates (as human saliva does).
3) Grain contain mostly complex carbohydrates - a group of nutrients dogs simply do not need, but can turn into energy to replace the fat they are much better utilizing.
4) Many dogs will lose excess weight when fed no grains.
5) Dogs fed kibble instead of a raw natural diet will have their life expectancy reduced by 30%. Kibble typically contain 70% grain products.
6) Most dogs do much better, health-wise, without much grain in their diet. No adverse effects have ever been documented for dogs that get no grain at all.

***Where grain would fit into the picture of a natural diet?***

Well, it doesn't really fit, does it?

There is one more aspect to be aware of, and that is the pH-level in the stomach that is needed for digestion of carbohydrates. It is generally around 6-7, close to neutral.

Raw food, however, takes a very low pH for an efficient digestion, typically below pH=2.

From this perspective alone, mixing substantial amounts of grain products into a raw diet is a very bad idea - it will cause the entire digestion process to run in an inefficient way. Smaller amounts of grain (such as less than 5% of a meal), however, will do no harm - but probably also not much good.

The tricky thing is that dogs could actually do quite well, at least short-term, on a meal that was almost exclusively made of grain products! This can have value for dogs that need to go gently on their stomach (keeping the pH around neutral is far less stressful than lowering it down to strong acidic levels).

For sick dogs, this can sometimes makes good sense. Also, for puppies that are too young to be able yet to digest raw food effectively without first having it predigested by their parents. And finally, for working dogs that need a fast energy boost for a specific performance that calls for a short burst of energy.

Mogens Eliasen holds a Ph.D. level degree in Chemistry from Århus University, Denmark and has 30+ years of experience working with dogs, dog owners, dog trainers, and holistic veterinarians as a coach, lecturer, and education system developer. He publishes a free newsletter "The Peeing Post" containing lots of tips and advice on dog problems of all kinds, particularly about training, behavioral problems, feeding, and health care.

For more information about Mogens Eliasen, including links to other articles he has published, please send a short e-mail to contact@k9joy.com


Back to Articles

Back to Health Issues"

Back to Home Page